When interior designer Gina Gutierrez and her husband Max Maloney were looking to purchase their first home, they faced a distinctly San Franciscan architectural challenge.

The couple wanted an open concept for their kitchen and living room, but that’s often impossible to create inside the city’s traditional houses. These classic structures, which date back to the early 20th century, are known for having multiple rooms along a single hallway. There’s usually a small kitchen and a separate living room at its far end, which often features the area’s famed bay windows.

But because of certain construction quirks, at least in the couple’s experience, renovators are often unable to tear down walls to connect the two spaces. So if this pair wanted to find their dream home, they’d have to stay focused—and probably get lucky. 

 

Before

a dark and cramped

The original kitchen was cramped at the back of the home, just like a standard layout in a traditional San Francisco property.

After

an open-concept kitchen with light green cabinetry.

“There were certain areas where we would splurge a little bit and others where we would scale back. We wanted to add value, but we didn’t want to break the bank at the same time,” Gutierrez says.

They found what they were looking for in their sixth house tour, an Edwardian home built in 1912. Located in Duboce Triangle, a neighborhood in the center of the city, the 1,180-square-foot property had the key element Gutierrez and Maloney wanted: The dividing wall between the living room and the kitchen could be safely removed. They bought the place, even though it needed a lot of work. 

“It had a lot of potential to be something more beautiful and open,” Gutierrez remembers.

Before

a dark and cramped

The original kitchen didn’t have enough space for an island and dining area to sit side-by-side.

After

the kitchen has a banquette.

In addition to offering a distinct place to dine, the bench seats open up for extra storage. It’s painted in Benjamin Moore’s Kendall Charcoal, and the Harwich Windsor dining chairs are from Target.

Once it was time to renovate, the couple maintained their attention to detail and collaborative effort. Gutierrez focused on the aesthetics, while Maloney used his background in mechanical engineering and product design to draw up sketches and models. “Our style is elevated comfort,” Gutierrez says. “We’re more traditional, but we like modern and bohemian elements. We also wanted to preserve a lot of character in the Edwardian house. We kept a lot of the millwork and board and batten, and we added arches that mimicked the one that was already in the hallway.”

The biggest structural change was the one they planned for all along.

They combined the kitchen—which was strangely too small for an island, but too big to be a galley—with the living room. “We blew half of the house into one big open room,” Maloney says.

Before

a dark and cramped

Despite having no prior experience, the couple refinished the existing pine floors themselves. They used a clear coat to let the natural color shine through.

After

the kitchen has a peninsula where friends can sit.

With the lighter floors, the couple was free to use bolder finishes. “I’ve always wanted brass, and this being our first house, I felt like I had to do it,” Gutierrez says. “At the same time, we try to balance the space between masculine and feminine tones and I do like how the brass brought a little softness and more warmth to the space.”

The couple loves to host dinner parties, so they made sure to have plenty of seating, starting with an L-shaped bench inspired by a local restaurant. It required an unusually long and skinny table, and they found a perfect one at the now-shuttered boutique Propeller. Next to it, they chose a peninsula made of Carrara marble from Integrated Resources Group, and paired it with Ikea bar stools that Maloney cut down to counter height. With that, Maloney and Gutierrez had more than enough room for a crowd.

“A lot of my clients don’t love working with marble because it can be pretty imperfect, but that’s actually what I love about it,” Gutierrez says. “The peninsula is a gathering space, so food and wine get on it. We clean it up, but it might leave markings. Because of that, I feel like it tells a story.”

Before

a kitchen sink the

The old sink was all about utility—and with the pig-shaped linen ring, perhaps a bit of humor.

After

a gold sink faucet matches a good sconce.

Maloney personally outfitted the cabinets with brass Schoolhouse hardware and Gutierrez chose a Newport Brass faucet and soap dispenser to match. “I think of those pieces like jewelry on the design, so I wanted them to be more high-end,” Gutierrez says.

As for the cabinets, she introduced Maloney to Semihandmade to get a high-end look for a budget-approved price—and the ability to figure out the best layout for Maloney’s meals.

“We immediately knew we wanted the Shaker style, and then we figured we would do the DIY just to customize and paint them whatever color we wanted,” she adds. They picked Benjamin Moore’s Coventry Gray, and positioned them in such a way so that Maloney can whip things up with ease.

The appliances were a different story: They didn’t mind splurging for the right ones, especially since a Viking range came with the house. “We actually purchased the refrigerator before doing any of the remodel work,” Gutierrez admits. “I’ve always really loved the Smeg refrigerators, but I didn’t want to go that retro because it wouldn’t be the best fit for this particular house. The GE refrigerator had a similar look, but a little more modern and with cleaner lines. We built everything around that refrigerator.”

Before

a living room with a desk, couch, and built-in bookcases.

The original living room’s bay window served as an office view.

After

a piano sits in front of brightly lit bay windows.

Now the bay window is the perfect backdrop for a small keyboard.

open shelving in the kitchen displays dishes and utensils.

Maloney partnered with a friend to craft the walnut floating shelves, and they also saved money by choosing the Ikea Barkaboda herringbone countertop. This allowed them to splurge on a herringbone marble backsplash from The Builder Depot. “I knew it would be a statement piece and have a bigger impact than paint,” Gutierrez says.

Once their attention could move on to the adjoining living area, they realized it only required some slight adjustments. Gutierrez and Maloney also used Semihandmade to expand the built-in shelving unit as a display for meaningful items, like photos and a record collection. The shelves flank a new gas fireplace that’s adorned with crackled Fireclay tile cut into triangles—a small detail that makes a big impact, which describes much of the renovation as a whole.

Looking back on the project, the couple wouldn’t do anything differently. The experience taught them patience and compromise, as well as which tasks they can DIY and which require an expert. “I learned that it’s definitely easier to remodel for myself,” Gutierrez says. “We can knock it out much faster. It’s dialed in because we know what we want.”

Before

built ins in the living room of a san francisco home.

Gutierrez and Maloney liked the original built-ins, but they thought they could benefit from a new, bigger layout.

After

built in bookshelves in a bright living room.

“We decided to invest a little bit of money to do a neat tile pattern for the fireplace, but nothing too heavy because the rest of the space is so calming and comforting,” Gutierrez says. The entire unit is painted in Benjamin Moore’s Chantilly Lace.

a blue couch in the living room

Now that the home’s living, dining, and kitchen areas have a unified layout, Gutierrez says it’s the perfect place to relax and entertain.

B+A’s Before You Go…

We had a quick chat with Gina Guiterrez on her design philosophy and favorite things. Read on to learn more about her…

Describe your renovation mantra in three sentences?

Design in a way that aligns with you.
Function and aesthetics can coexist.
Design sustainably to take care of the earth.

What are your favorite stores for one-of-a-kind finds?

Earthen
Sobu 
The Vintage Rug Shop
Bloomist
Cindy Zell
Xinhandco Goods

Who do you follow on Instagram for inspiration?

Jean Stoffer Design
Lindy Galloway
Planted in the Woods
Fireclay Tile
The Good Future Design Alliance
Floret Flower 

What’s the one thing in your home you couldn’t live without?

Ever since I discovered Parachute in 2014, I haven’t been able to purchase other bedding. The percale sheets are my favorite, although I also own the linen sheets, a cozy quilt, and two different duvet covers! 

What’s one meal you’re always whipping up in your kitchen?

My husband and I love trying new recipes—we love following Tieghan Gerard on Half Baked Harvest to do so. But our go-to dinner is tacos. I love making homemade tortillas, and then we create beef, chicken, or shrimp tacos together. We’ll whip up a salsa that may have mango, pineapple, and cilantro in it, too. But on a really good day, we’ll even make some margaritas!

Real Stories,
reno stories, life stories.

Tips and ideas from SemiStories straight to your inbox.
I’m in! Sign me up.

Thank you for subscribing!